Comparing uPVC vs. Aluminum Double Glazing

With over 60% of heat escaping through windows in homes, installing energy efficient double glazing brings vital insulation benefits. However, choosing final frames containing your glazing requires weighing up uPVC vs. aluminium Double Glazing options carefully considering performance, lifespan, sustainability and visual impacts.

While uPVC and aluminium frames both offer durable low maintenance solutions, subtle differences separate their capabilities and costs. This comprehensive guide compares every facet guiding you towards the best double glazing material option matching your home and climate.

We’ll cover insulating values, acoustic ratings, longevity comparisons, material sustainability, aesthetic options and vital installation considerations helping select between both frame varieties with confidence.

Framing The Great Window Frame Debate: uPVC or Aluminium?

Recent decades witnessed the meteoric rise of uPVC displacing traditional timber frames as mainstream double glazing choice in many regions based on affordable insulating properties and low maintenance appeal.

However aluminium profiles brought distinct structural strengths and slick contemporary visuals into the frame material mix too. This introduced a broadening range of options and uncertainty around ideal picks.

To kick start the battle between both evergreen contenders, check out this concise comparison overview:

Frame MaterialKey StrengthsConsiderations
uPVCBudget friendly Good insulation
Colour stability
Can discolour
Less structural rigidity
Cheaper aesthetic
AluminiumSuper strong
Sleek modern looks
Effective rain drainage
Conducts more heat
Higher cost

Next we’ll gauge how they compare tackling common performance factors more closely, from insulation credentials and sound dampening through to eco impacts and appearance.

Thermal Efficiency And Insulation Credentials

Arguably the prime consideration assessing double glazing frames becomes assessing effectiveness preventing precious internal heat leaking outside, with gaps potentially sinking energy conservation efforts.

So how do uPVC and aluminium thermal transmission rates and insulation values compare?

uPVC FramesAluminium Frames
Material ConductivityLower conductivity
Slows heat transfer
Metal composition conducts warmth faster
Common U-Values1.2 to 1.41.8 to 2.2
Standard Option U-ValueU-1.4U-2.2
Thermal BreaksN/A – already insulatedThermal barriers inserted to mimic uPVC performance

The table reveals standard uPVC frames broadly rate 30-50% better resisting heat flows based on their non-conductive polymer composition.

However, inserting advanced thermal breaks between exterior and interior aluminium sections nearly bridges performance gaps when specified. Note glass pane choices also remain equally important!

Noise Reduction And Acoustic Capabilities

Beyond just retaining warmth, we expect tranquility from our homes buffering external noise irritations like traffic or aircraft. So how do sound dampening capabilities of uPVC and aluminium framing compare?

uPVC FramesAluminium Frames
Material DensitySolid and denseHollow metal can echo
Glass Air TightnessSimilar sealing effectivenessSimilar sealing effectiveness when well constructed
Optional UpgradesLaminated/acoustic glass choicesLaminated/acoustic glass choices
Typical Noise Reduction25-30 db solid performance25-30 db equivalency achievable

Results reveal properly sealed aluminium can match uPVC noise insulation through smart material combinations, despite their hollow construction seeming to reverberate initially.

Structural Rigidity And Wind Loading Resistance

Frames must withstand years buffeted by extreme weather and wind pressure loads without leaking or compromising glass connections. Build quality trumps materials here. Lets see how structural stability odds stack up:

Frame RigidityDecent flex resistance but can bowExcellent rigidity and stiffness
Glass BondingStable glazing channelsStable glazing channels
ReinforcingSteel inserts add strengthInherent strength
WeatherproofingJoint seals degrade fasterJoint seals degrade faster
Typical Building Stories2-3 stories well6 stories + proven

Fairly conclusively, aluminium framing brings vastly superior mechanical capabilities through solid precise unit construction resistant warping long-term. Multi-story and exposed applications suit aluminium frames ideally where wind loads intensify.

Environmental Sustainability And Lifespan Comparison

Beyond core functionality, eco-conscious homeowners want energy efficiency without costing the earth through framing life cycles. Which frame material proves more sustainable long-term?

Typical Lifespan30-40 years30-40 years
Material ProductionHigh virgin plastic usage and chemical outputsHigh mineral mining and smelting energy consumption
Low rate currently
High recyclable via remelting
Typical replacementsGlass units replacedWhole frames reused
Embodied Carbon2.5 to 5 tonnes CO2 per ton8 to 13 tonnes CO2 per ton

Well-made frames of either material remain serviceable for 30+ years before maintenance concerns arise. However aluminium holds superior reuse potential if initial production footprints seem more environmentally taxing presently.

Visual Appearance, Finish And Style Options

Finally, aesthetics likely play pivotal role influencing decisions between frame materials fulfilling stylish façades. So how do appearance options compare?

Color ChoicesDiverse colors and imitation wood effectsDiverse color options
Texture FinishesLower quality flat through to texturedPowder coated, anodized and timber seat options
Profile StylesSmall range of rounded profilesVast modular shapes and dimensions available
Frame SightlinesThicker framesSlimmer sightlines possible

Fairly conclusively, sleek contemporary architectural visions shine brighter with aluminium range flexibility, while more classic period aesthetics possibly suit softer uPVC moulding lines and convincing wood replications.

How Do Costs Compare Between uPVC And Aluminium Framing?

Pricing proves pivotal influencing double glazing frame preferences for most homeowners. As broad indicators, check average supply and install rates below:

Base Material Supply Cost£135 to £165 per m2£170 to £215 per m2
Typical Install Cost£60 to £110 per m2£75 to £135 per m2
Total Cost Estimate£195 to £275 per m2£245 to £350 per m2

The base rates above demonstrate aluminium framing demands 15% to 30% higher initial budget overall. However improved insulation performance, structural capabilities or aesthetic appeal may balance added expenditures for some.

With window costs fluctuating based on exact specifications like opening types, sizes, building difficulties and finishes, obtain firm installed quotes tailored your project from recommended fabricators comparing steel vs timber vs aluminium solutions on a level playing field.

4 Key Double Glazing Frame Selection Considerations

After weighing up all performance, sustainability, lifespan and appearance merits between both undeniable frame contenders, keep these 4 vital factors front of mind making final decisions:

🔎 Consider long term budget – higher aluminium spend could justify over 30 years via energy and replacement savings to assess heat vs cost equations realistically.

🔬 Reference climate conditions – maximize insulation and noise dampening in cold/noisy regions by minimizing metal content.

🏠 Mind home aesthetics – more ornate classical architecture suits uPVC flexibility as aluminium shines delivering clean contemporary lines.

👷‍♂️ Demand quality installations – perfectly sealed frames prevent air leakage sinking efficiency gains regardless of material.

Frame The Future Through Eco And Expert Window Selections

Hopefully dissecting the split decision between evergreen uPVC against aluminium frame options for double glazing helped steer preferences matching home plans.

Keep in mind precision fabrication and robust window connections prove equally vital maintaining energy efficiencies long term regardless of base material verdicts. Be sure to liaise reputable brands offering strong weatherproof warranties installing either frame medium impeccably.

Take the time considering aesthetic and performance tradeoffs between both offerings suited to housing architecture visions, climate realities and budgets for enduring comfort. Take advantage of free frame material consultations and quotes to decisively finalize the optimum window foundations driving household sustainability for decades ahead!

Ready To Start A New Project With Cornwall Window Repairs?